.

Cafeteria Workers Plead for Jobs

Superintendent, Board of Education chair say deficit "is not your fault."

Farmington cafeteria workers went before the Board of Education Monday night, making a last plea for their jobs on a night when the board considered two companies for outsourcing the district’s food service operations.

About a dozen women crowded into the meeting, held in the Farmington High School library, to speak during the board’s public comment period. They stood alongside an equal number of suited representatives of the food service companies.

Most explained how the children they serve are like family to them.

"At the cafeteria, I see almost all the children every day,” said Lori Manyak. “They come through the line and it’s important they see a friendly face. We all care about all the children. Most of us had children and grandchildren in the schools. I wish you could see how hard we work.”

She also said she wished the employees, who work for the school district, could have been given more notice to get their finances in order.

The workers were told in meetings with administrators about six weeks before the end of school that the district would be putting cafeteria services out to bid to explore cost-saving options. Over the past two years, administrators say, Farmington school cafeterias have lost $110,000 — $55,000 each year.

Director Janet Calabro had tried a number of different tactics to try to increase revenue, including abandoning a grant program that mandated healthy offerings, introducing new menu options and opening a store in the Farmington High School café. None have succeeded in reversing the loss.

Sharon Bonini, the manager at West Woods Upper Elementary grew up in Farmington, as did her parents, grandparents and children. She opened the West Woods cafeteria when the school was built 10 years ago and managed East Farms prior to that. She assured the board that with the right leadership, the program could be righted.

“I take great pride in my work for the town, schools and children I serve,” she said. “Private vendors often cut corners to increase profits in the meals they serve – we don’t do that. I don’t believe any private vendor will give our students better service than we do… I understand it’s impossible to keep running in a deficit but there are many changes we can make as a department… cutting hours, even maybe possibly a few positions.”

Her mother, Diane Turner, said she had spent 25 years at Farmington High School and the past 15 years at Irving A Robbins.

“Many of our kitchen employees also have children in the Farmington school system, which makes us more like family than just workers. The students are all our friends and our neighbors – we care deeply for them, like family – they’re not just business. At the last meeting …I was very impressed by how much the board cares for the students and takes care of them, I ask you don’t fail them by bringing in a food service place. Give us another chance,” Turner said.

Board Chairman Mary Grace Reed told the women the decision to look for an outside vendor was not a reflection on their work.

“You’ve absolutely not failed us. I don’t want you to walk out of this room for a moment and think the love you have given to our students and the concern and effort you put into the product you put before them is not meaningful,” Reed said, noting that the combined total of their years of services would be in the hundreds.

“We are in an extremely challenging situation with our budget. We cannot just go in and say to the Town Council that we’re going to have a $50,000 deficit in our cafeteria budget… They would not allow us to run a deficit and fund it.”

Reed said she had heard rumors that the board had already made a decision, which she said was absolutely untrue. She also said the board was not looking to lay blame for the deficit.

Superintendent Kathleen Greider explained that the problem was systemic and not the fault of the workers.

“We truly respect and honor your service here in Farmington,” Greider said. “I don’t ever want you to think this has anything to do with you as our employees. This is a system problem we had and certainly your employment is part of our deliberations. We have to find a way to honor all of you and remedy a system problem that we are facing. We can not run this program as it is currently being run. We have a fund balance that is being depleted and after this year we are in a crisis situation.”

Though the board met for several hours in executive session and heard from two food service companies, members did not make a decision, though they met until after midnight. A special meeting will be held, tentatively scheduled for June 26, to take action on the issue.

Nancy Swanson June 19, 2012 at 12:00 PM
"Cafeteria Workers Plead for their Jobs". Shame on Farmington for even considering this. How humiliating for these hard workers that are part of our town! Let's attack some more workers at the bottom of the pay scale.
Sas June 19, 2012 at 12:07 PM
Shame, Shame, Shame!!!!!!
Sas June 19, 2012 at 12:20 PM
Sharon said it...."with the right leadership". That is what has been lacking!
LL June 19, 2012 at 12:41 PM
How to make money? Offer good healthy locally sourced food choices. Make it delicious - something the kids will love and the parents will feel good about having their kids eat and the money will pour in. Give theses ladies the support and proper resources to make it work. Sending our money put of town is the WRONG solution.
Andrea Buono June 19, 2012 at 01:11 PM
I will be very disappointed in our board of ed if they do hire an outside vendor. I support our current cafeteria workers, who are "our family". I have lived in this town all my life and it is nice to go back to some of these schools and see some familar faces who have worked for the school cafe for years. There are endless ways to generate revenue for our cafeterias, many towns have done it. The wrong approach has been taken and from this we have felt the affects. The health and nutrition commitee needs to reevaluate thier priorities and get our school lunch program back on track and keep the current staff.
Deb June 19, 2012 at 01:44 PM
I hope the Board is looking at neighboring towns that turned to outside vendors for food service. Canton specifically, what a disaster that has turned out to be. The town may not have to deal with a deficit, but the food is horrible, the nutrition is lacking, and the morale of the workers is less than caring. I've been there, seen that. Farmington deserves better. I hope the Board does the right thing and supports these hard working and caring ladies.
stephanie smith June 19, 2012 at 01:49 PM
I have lived in this town my entire life as have many of my friends and neighbors. This has been a topic at many local gatherings lately. Nobody can believe that our town would out source. I still bump into my children's "lunch ladies" and I know that they keep an eye on all of our children in and out of the cafeteria. It takes a village to raise our children, not strangers. I would also be very disappointed in our town if they take an outside bid. Great article Kaitlin. Is there anything we can do to stop this?
Janet Colturi June 19, 2012 at 01:54 PM
Very disappointing that the BOE would take such a negative action against the cafeteria workers. It is really hard to believe that over a dozen worker's jobs would be eliminated to save $50,000!! Another example of poor choices by the BOE and school administration.
Nancy Swanson June 19, 2012 at 02:01 PM
Let's hope the Board of Ed, Town Council members AND the Superintendent of Schools are paying close attention to our comments. Perhaps we should show up in mass at the next meeting? We, as VOTERS, should also remember who supported this action.
Megan McArdle Parsons June 19, 2012 at 02:06 PM
It is the job of the food service company is to come to schools and sell the school on how profitable they can be. Do not think for one moment that they are there to look after your children. They are there to make money, bottom line. They will do what ever needs to be done to see that they have a profit. Where are all the parents who I saw stand and speak at the TC meeting pleading for them to pass and not cut the Ed budget? Get involved in this! This is an integral part of your child’s daily school life. Allow the people who have worked in the school system help in solving this problem and move forward. Outsourcing to an outside food service company is a lazy way to solve a fixable problem. Set an example for these kids.
Saul Freedman June 19, 2012 at 02:41 PM
What a shame that the Democrat led and dominated BOE is taking out their budget woes on these hard working cafeteria ladies..... while the teachers parade around proclaiming what heroes they are for taking a 0% increase this year. How long has it been since these fine workers got a pay raise? How about you reading this?
unavailable June 19, 2012 at 02:50 PM
As one of the workers whose job is in jeopardy I wholeheartedly agree. We have sent letters and suggestions to resolve the problem, but the answer we are given is "nothing has been decided yet, there are other options" but they don't say what those options are. I attended the meeting last night with my speech in hand, but ended up not presenting it. It seemed like a waste of time, given the tone of the meeting, and it just didn't seem worth it to get upset again when there doesn't seem like there is anything we can do or say to help the situation. The BOE is going to make the decision and their word is final. If you attended the meeting you heard the chair state that Westwoods golf course also is in a deficit situation, but that is a different case and we shouldn't compare the two. Why not? it is the same town and uses your tax dollars too. When I woke up at 4am unable to sleep, thinking of my future job or lack of one, depending on the BOE's decision, I thought of a simple, at least partial fix, that some of your high paid accountants haven't suggested. There are approximately 34-35 cafeteria workers in the system, and using a salary figure of $14-$15 per hour for a school year of 180 days, if every employee cut their hours by 1/2 hour per day, the Town would save between $42,000 and $46,000 per year. If the insurance eligibilty was grandfathered in for those that already have it may be a win,win for everyone.
Susan Kasmar June 19, 2012 at 03:29 PM
I have had five children in the school system. All of them have come home and talked about how much they love their lunch ladies. When my second and third children entered West Woods they were scared. It was such a comfort for them to see Mrs. Turner-Bonini (a familar face around town). My other two children have been at Union and they love and adore Miss Lisa. Our children form bonds with these ladies. Bringing in an outside company, is bringing strangers in our town and around our children. Find a way to make it work and keep the ladies here that our children know and love and feel safe and secure!!!!!
Susan Kasmar June 19, 2012 at 03:31 PM
If everyone remembers Miss Kim was involved with our children and in the lunch room everyday. You see how much of an impact these ladies have on our children!!!
Nancy Swanson June 19, 2012 at 03:47 PM
I just sent a personal email to all the Board members. All the emails of the Board members can be found online. Let's bombard them with correspondence (and I have no children left in the system so have nothing personal to gain). Maybe it's time for the Working Families Party to get more active in Farmington and get rid of any Republican or Democrat that supports this measure. Their name says it all.
Sas June 19, 2012 at 03:58 PM
I will forward all of these great letters. Keep it up! I don't know of a more important issue right now than saving these positions. This school system does not need outsourcing! Perfect Saul!!!!!
Sas June 19, 2012 at 03:59 PM
Oh and for sure Miss Kim is looking down on this situation!
denise lysak June 19, 2012 at 05:27 PM
It is unfortunate that the BOE is entertaining the idea of outsourcing this dedicated staff. Outsourcing will bring poor food selections to Farmington students. If Farmington wants top notch students performing at their academic best, the cafeteria staff that coordinates the meals for Farmington students should not be relieved of their positions. Nutritional meals fuel our kids to advance academically. The dedicated staff, knowing the parents and the students have relationships that build trust. I'm happy to know that if my child isn't eating what he/she should be a member of the staff in school would always let me know of their food choices so that I could discuss their selections at home. It would be a shame to lose such a powerful staff that assists our children in making proper food choices, setting the course for healthy adults in the future.
Robert Huelin June 19, 2012 at 07:42 PM
As a parent who is concerned about the quality of the food in the schools, I think there is much room for improvement. This is about parents choosing not to purchase school lunches because of concerns about the quality. And the goal of any new vendor selection should be to improve the quality of the food options to attract more children to buy school lunch. I question the framing of this issue as a movement to replace the current cafeteria workers---in the other food service vendor changes I'm familiar with (some at schools, some at corporate cafeterias), the service staff (the wonderful women who work at the schools) is held over by the new vendor. It is not uncommon for the buyer to insist that, as a condition of awarding the contract, the new vendor commit to retaining most of the existing workforce, and I hope the School Board will consider imposing a like condition as part of this process. As far as I know, both from talking to other parents and from raising my own concerns with Board of Ed members, this is and should be about improving food quality not changing staff. Anything less than improved food options for the kids represents a failure of this process, regardless of who is serving the food.
Sas June 19, 2012 at 10:29 PM
Unavailable. Thank you.
Megan McArdle Parsons June 20, 2012 at 01:07 PM
I have worked for several food vendors and have first hand knowledge of the quality of food the students will get. Believe me, they are not going to the farmers market to get the produce. And I also have first hand knowledge of the transition of being an employee of a school that takes on a contraced food service vendor. If the BOE really wants to improve on the quality of food, they can only do so by keeping control of their caffeteria and looking for solutions to cut costs and improve qualitiy. This can be done within the existing system, which would just need to break even, not make a profit. On a side note, nutrition begins at home. If children are not exposed to good nutrition there, then they are not going to opt for it at school.
Stephanie stewart July 07, 2012 at 09:48 AM
Absolutely!

Boards

More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something